top of page

Measuring Body Composition

Method Health
Oct 11, 2024
13 min read

Updated: Nov 10

Measuring your body composition (or the ratio of fat to non-fat components of your body) is done for several practical reasons at gyms. Measures of muscle mass, fat mass/percentage, or/and bone density independently change after months of weight training or a fat loss period. Even if your goal is to improve “general health”, ensuring that body fat and muscle mass levels are healthy across your lifespan is worth checking annually. 


Contents (click on a heading to skip to its section):



Why should you care about fat percentage or muscle mass?


“OK, how do I best measure them?” 

  • Answering that question is the purpose of this article. Fortunately for saving your time, only three methods are efficient in terms of cost, time, and access. What measure to use and the frequency of use depend on your goals. 

  • Unfortunately, none of these measures is 100% accurate and only estimates body fat percentage or true lean mass (this can only be determined after death, by dissecting and weighing all the different tissues in the body). Therefore, you must be aware of and comfortable with the error range inherent in all these measures (Body composition changes in bodybuilders: a method comparison). 

  • Often, for all these measures, the best time of day to perform them is immediately after waking, with minimal clothing on and after using the toilet, to reduce water retention and faecal material in the gastrointestinal tract, which can interfere with body composition measures. However, some of the options below may not be accessible as soon as you get out of bed, so consider this in relation to the accuracy of your body composition results. 

The following three methods have been chosen and described in order of ease of completion, cost of access, simplicity, and helpfulness in using each measure in your best interest. Use each or all as you see fit.


Visual guides


Cons of this measure:

  • Unfortunately, visual guides can increase body image focus and reduce long-term focus on health. 

  • Might feel initially uncomfortable showing it to someone else, but other people are the best judges of your current leanness from visual guides.

  • 2-5% error range


Bodyweight scale

Cons of this measure:

  • Bodyweight scales, even “Smart Scales” (Diving Deep into Smart Scales: Are They a Game-Changer or Gimmick?) do not give you an accurate body fat percentage, so visual guides are still needed. Your body weight change also does not reliably indicate changes in muscle mass. This is why there is no known “best” body weight and body weight on its own cannot be used to predict health as some who assume they are healthy based only on their body weight actually still have excess body fat (Excess body fat in obese and normal-weight subjects). Combine body weight with other body fat estimates.

  • Most bodyweight scales machines are pretty accurate if the scale is on flat ground. However, there is a 1-3kg difference in measurement between different scales, even of the same brand and type.

  • Socially, body weight can initiate a sense of shame or weight stigma, which is a barrier for seeking assistance with improving body composition (Perceptions of barriers to effective obesity management). Many might be averse to tracking body weight when trying to lose weight due to this shame, having thoughts like “I do not want to lose weight but only lose fat,” not realising they are very reflective of each other. So if you are not concerned about your weight, you should not be concerned about your body fat percentage.

    • Instead of focusing on your body weight number and any indirect social meaning this has, emphasize celebrating the change of this number each week. I.e. if you are now 78 kg due to losing 2 kg in the last month, celebrate the 2 kg loss rather than now being 78 kg.

  • This method does not account for body water losses during weight loss and normal daily fluctuations. So, females might not be drawn to this method due to more significant body water changes influenced by their menstrual cycle week to week compared to males. If you believe daily changes in body water are blocking you from seeing weight loss across a week, just switch to measuring change across a month instead. So compare weight in week 1 of your cycle to week 1 of the next to best avoid the in-between fluctuations. 


Bioelectric impedance analysis (BIA)

  • We have a BIA machine at Method Health. All you need to do is stand on a metal stand without shoes and hold the device with each hand. Values are calculated based on how much a safe electrical charge going between your feet and hands is “impeded” or interfered in transmission (Stratification of Fat‐Free Mass Index Percentiles for Body Composition). This provides an estimate of how much body fat and muscle mass you have from standardised equations. 

  • It takes less than 5 minutes to add your details (age, height, goals, and an email address to send the result) and to complete the scan.

Cons of this measure:

  • BIA shouldn’t be used if you have a heart pacemaker, use hearing aids, or are known to be pregnant. If you have a joint replacement or breast implant, completing the measure is safe, but these will be interpreted as fat tissue.

  • Just like for body weight scales, BIA accuracy is impacted by hydration. So aim to complete your BIA, at the same time of the morning each testing session with as little previous fluid, food, exercise, or caffeine consumed before testing. Or try and standardise these, on the day and days before testing. Results are also affected by the time of day and external temperature so just be consistent with your testing time. These factors can make this method not very practical for most to get an accurate measure.  

  • Current BIA-based equation over-estimates muscle mass, while also having a 10% error range of body fat percentage (Skeletal muscle estimation: A review of techniques and their applications - Rodriguez - 2024 + Bioelectrical impedance analysis in the health field: a still scientifically fragile tool for body composition assessment + Skeletal muscle estimation: A review of techniques and their applications). However, this is 90% better than the body weight scale which does not tell you your body fat percentage or total muscle mass. Equations will improve in the next decade to likely become very accurate. Overall, it's just best not to use BIA too often or expect it to be 100% accurate. 


So overall, combining visual guides, bodyweight scales and BIA can give you a good estimate of how much muscle and fat you have and can give you a good month to month guide on how your lifestyle and exercise habits are influencing these important components of your body composition (Methodological standards for body composition- an expert-endorsed guide for research and clinical applications: levels, models, and terminology + Skeletal muscle estimation: A review of techniques and their applications). 


What about waist circumference?

  • Waist circumference is a quick indicator of amounts of fat mass around your midsection and often induces less self-critical thoughts than bodyweight measures. Aim for less than 80cm for females and 94 cm for males (How do you measure your waist? (youtube.com)). Its cheap as it only requires a flexible tape measure. However, 1) it doesn't help measure change when you are already at a low body fat level, 2) only shows significant changes, which despite being a really positive health indicator, limits use for measuring week to week changes, 3) doesn't predict body fat percentage and 4) doesn’t tell you the amount of full body muscle you have. 


Is body mass index (BMI) useful?

You can see as a trend BMI can estimate fat percentage across large group, but two individuals of the same BMI can have different body fat percentages, a number which matters more to be aware of (Accuracy of Body Mass Index to Diagnose Obesity In the US Adult Population).


Less practical or cost-efficient options

  • DEXA is the gold standard for measuring bone mass (while not as much for muscle mass, as body water interferes with the measurement of your muscle), but it is limited in most cities, expensive, and involves low radiation exposure while lying very still for 10 min, which limits how often you should be tested each year (International society of sports nutrition position stand: diets and body composition). Seek info from out article if you are interested in or at risk of bone or fall-related health problems - Method Health- Bone Health. 

  • MRI or Ultrasound imaging can be the most accurate method of measuring fat and muscle mass without any radiation exposure (International society of sports nutrition position stand: diets and body composition). Obtaining and interpreting these images, however, involves significant expertise and cost, which are not practical for most. When MRIs (or other technology for digital visual scanning) become more accessible (and less overused for unhelpful medical purposes (Imaging Myths - E3 Rehab), and cost heaps less, these will be encouraged more often for regular body composition assessment. 

  • Bod-pods (gas-based) or underwater weighing (water-based): This involves submersion within a harmless gas pod or water, with the use of equations to predict how your weight differs from how much you displace water (which is different for different levels of fat and muscle levels). However, these methods are hard to access, often cost a lot and still have a less than practical error range. 

  • Skinfold measurements? Previously it was popular to use prediction equations of body fat percentage calculated by measuring the sum of “skinfold” at multiple sites around the body. However, despite being cheap and quick to measure, skinfold estimation does not predict muscle mass and available equations have a less than practical error range even when the measurement is completed by a very experienced “skin-folder” (Comparison of Eight Equations That Predict Percent Body Fat Using Skinfolds). Therefore skin folds are really only useful if trying to lose body fat and you don’t want to use visual scales or bodyweight scales and you have access to an experienced assessor.




What's the most helpful way to measure increasing muscle mass? 

  • Measuring an increase in ability to lift more weight for 8-10 repetitions of a certain body part exercise. So, not a scan or scale, but this is the most useful way for assessing increases in muscle which can only really be measured reliably after months of lifting weights (How to know if you're gaining muscle?). First, you are completing progressive strength training, evident by ability to perform 8-10 repetitions of a specific body part exercise with increasingly more weight, which optimally you have not practised in the preceding month. Second, this will be plus or minus your bodyweight increasing by 1-3kg a month (Is an Energy Surplus Required to Maximize Skeletal Muscle Hypertrophy Associated With Resistance Training). With both criteria met you can guarantee yourself that around a third of your new body weight (or more for some lucky or new to lifting people (Variability in muscle size and strength gain after unilateral resistance training) is new muscle and lean mass in the body part you tested. For example, if your hip thrust weight for 8-10 repetitions increases after months of only squatting, plus or minus bodyweight gain, you have likely gained gluteal muscle mass. 



To summarise, this article clarifies everything you need to know to measure your body composition accurately for life. Whether it's weight loss, muscle mass gain, or yearly maintenance, mindful use of body weight scales, visual guides, and BIA can help best measure healthy body composition, until better technology is invented. Other methods are available but are inaccurate, costly, and less accessible or feasible for daily or weekly use. 

Contact our Method Health team members for questions and guidance on realistic body composition goals, support for improving fat loss (Method Health- Fat Loss Support), and how to use body composition methods to measure your progress or track important health indicators. We understand that body weight and body composition can carry a stigma attached to their measurement or evoke feelings of embarrassment regarding previous weight loss attempts. We all understand this and aim as a coaching group to stay health-centred while following evidence-based principles to reduce body composition stigma and help many reach their healthy body composition goals (Joint international consensus statement for ending stigma of obesity + Demystifying Obesity: Understanding, Prevention, Treatment, and Stigmas).

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page