The Athletic Grumpy Hip Joint
Medically called “femoracetabular impingement” (FAI), but can more helpfully be thought of as hip joint pain not related to osteoarthritis (Osteoarthritis-Related Joint Pain Management).

How common is it?
The most common cause of pain around your upper leg and hip joint in those under 50 years old (Oxford consensus on primary cam morphology and femoroacetabular impingement syndrome). It is very common in field-based team sports in Australia, like football and soccer (Orchard: Results of 2 decades of injury surveillance).
Clues or common symptoms?
Symptoms around the hip, lower back, bum, groin, and down the thigh can be quite broad and vary from individual to individual with hip pain (Diagnostic accuracy of clinical tests for cam or pincer morphology in individuals with suspected FAI syndrome + Sensory Innervation of the Hip Joint and Referred Pain). Clicking, catching, stiffness, and/or pain around the muscles at the front of the hip are not unusual for this type of hip pain, and it is the intolerance to these symptoms that makes them important to ask about, rather than their mere presence.
Perceptions of pain and stiffness can be initiated by deep hip-bending and rotation movements (see image below). However, know that 1) these movements can be sore for many without concern of hip pain (The FADIR test accuracy), and 2) are not accurate at telling us the part of the hip joint that is sore, such as the hip bone, thigh bone, or soft tissue around the hip (Physical impairments in symptomatic FAI).
Be sceptical of being told you have hip cartilage or “labral” pain, which means pain in the soft tissue triangular covering around the edge of the hip joint, after these movement assessments. They rarely occur in isolation from a general grumpy hip, we cannot detect that accurately with movement assessments (Hip pain referral patterns in patients with labral tears: analysis based on intra-articular anesthetic injections, hip arthroscopy, and a new pain "circle" diagram + The diagnostic accuracy of a clinical examination in determining intra-articular hip pain for potential hip arthroscopy candidates + What is the role of clinical tests and ultrasound in acetabular labral tear diagnostics?) and you can have hip cartilage (What is the prevalence of imaging-defined intra-articular hip pathologies in people with and without pain?) and labral changes without pain (Similar Prevalence of Acetabular Labral Tear in Professional Ballet Dancers and Sporting Participants + Acetabular Labral Tears Are Common in Asymptomatic Contralateral Hips). Also these changes might not matter anyway as you can have improved symptoms without a change in labrum structure (Femoroacetabular impingement syndrome and labral injuries: grading the evidence on diagnosis and non-operative treatment).
Also, hip flexor pain is commonly blamed as the original source of hip pain, but it is more often a consequence of hip joint pain, rather than the cause (Hip Flexor Pain).

When is it not only a "grumpy" hip joint pain, and might require more specific advice than what is provided in this article? - See the resources at the end of the article for assistance with these, for what resources have not been provided in this next section.
It would be unusual for this type of hip pain to present with an inability to hop or run, symptoms that would better predict bone stress conditions. However, when a hip joint flare-up is severe, they can present similarly (Stress fractures - a detailed thread + The E3 Rehab Podcast: High vs. Low-Risk Bone Stress Injuries w/ Steph Mundt).
Irritability of the hip in multiple directions and positions, not fitting the symptoms of this type of hip joint pain, could also be a clue to temporarily symptomatic hip dysplasia. Both types of hip conditions can occur together (Prevalence and morphological features of acetabular dysplasia with coexisting femoroacetabular impingement-related findings).
Abdominal muscle pain can be referred to the hip and groin. We would be looking for symptoms provoked by coughing or sneezing, or for irritable sensations or physically palpable lumps in this region (Doha agreement meeting on terminology and definitions in groin pain in athletes | British Journal of Sports Medicine + Clinical examination for athletes with inguinal-related groin pain).
Symptoms originating only from the groin muscles and/or tendons can be managed using principles similar to those for hip joint pain (Return to Sport After Criteria-Based Rehabilitation of Acute Adductor Injuries in Male Athletes).
“Snapping” tendons are a distinct condition but share management strategies with hip joint pain (Snapping Hip Syndrome Rehab (Education | Myths | Stretching & Strengthening Exercises)).
Similar signs, but in adults older than 50, are more likely to be best managed as hip osteoarthritis (OA), which, non-surgically, is not very different from what helps manage this type of hip joint pain (Does This Patient Have Hip Osteoarthritis? The Rational Clinical Examination Systematic Review - PMC). Hip joint pain in young adulthood can contribute to hip OA later in life.
Although the hip is changing shape in early active teenage years (Cam Morphology: Development and Prevention), hip pain in individuals younger then 12-14 is unlikely to be this type of hip pain, but can still be non-concerning (Medical self check starter page - young painHEALTH + Defining Growing Pains).
Bladder, bowel, digestion, and nerve-related changes can affect the groin and hip and often present with more confusing symptoms, but many can still be addressed with high-quality hip health strategies (Why Your Hip Hurts - E3 Rehab).
What is wrong?
The simple answer is that tolerance to the upper leg contacting the hip joint has decreased. Bony pain in this area can also cause a temporary nuisance of other local muscle symptoms, like a noisy neighbor playing loud music at night. These combinations of phenomena can occur in any joint, but hip symptoms are more common in adults younger than 50 years who have not tolerated or adapted to a recent increase in hip-related activities, such as running, kicking, and squatting. Often, bony changes in the hip joint occur as a seemingly “protective” adaptation to extensive running and sports during the early teenage years (How does the cam morphology develop in athletes? A systematic review and meta-analysis - PubMed). Years later, these bone shape changes, although for many hips can remain asymptomatic (Prevalence of Femoroacetabular Impingement Imaging Findings in Asymptomatic Volunteers: A Systematic Review - PubMed), during periods of increased running and sport, can predispose an active person to a sore hip, just like in any joint after doing “too much, too soon.” Then, many often struggle through a vicious cycle of well-intentioned rest meant to help calm symptoms, which instead reduces tolerance for future hip loading. This is followed by too-quick attempts to return to regular activities, leaving the hip sore again, and then more rest, and the cycle repeats. These common experiences leave a person with a sore hip confused, concerned, and unsure how to get out of this cycle without support. Often unhelpful beliefs about the cause of hip pain, perceived impact on tolerance and concern of future pain worsening to previously really enjoyable movements contribute more to hip pain levels than the extent of hip joint imaging changes (Preoperative Symptoms in Femoroacetabular Impingement Patients Are More Related to Mental Health Scores Than the Severity of Labral Tear or Magnitude of Bony Deformity - The Journal of Arthroplasty).
What can I do about it?
Best management options aim to improve hip health without excessive medical intervention (Mike Reiman FAI - YouTube), similar to what is encouraged for hip osteoarthritis (Hip Osteoarthritis - E3 Rehab + OA Optimism). Either the condition increases the risk of future hip osteoarthritis, or pain behaviours common in persistent hip pain, such as decreased physical activity, weight gain, and reduced mental health, contribute to long-term worsening of joint health.
If periods of rest and non-rushed return to regular active hobbies have not helped (as it doesn’t for some), it would be helpful to seek care to improve strength, balance, and speed of the hip with guidance from an exercise specialist (don't assume every physiotherapist or exercise coach is highly knowledgeable about exercise therapy for painful conditions). Sometimes, all you need is a simple progression plan to improve your tolerance for painful hip movement beyond your current level. Simple does not mean easy, as this gradual progression often requires months of patient persistence to return to the previous tolerance for all normal active hip movements.
You should not feel “rushed” into surgery for this type of hip pain. Only 20% of people will feel the perceived need for surgery after months of non-surgical management, and even this number might be too high, as the quality of the exercise encouraged in these non-surgical management studies is pretty low (Is exercise therapy for femoroacetabular impingement in or out of FASHIoN? We need to talk about current best practice for the non-surgical management of FAI syndrome | British Journal of Sports Medicine + Improving function in people with hip-related pain), no sham surgery trials have been done, so its hard to know if the benefit of surgery is the “permession” for forced rest, allowing a sensitive hip to calm down, and then intentionally slow and progressive exercise that occurs after surgery to increase your tolerance to all hip movements regardless of the hip shape (Hip arthroscopy versus best conservative care for the treatment of femoroacetabular impingement syndrome (UK FASHIoN): a multicentre randomised controlled trial - PMC). We have seen this positive effect of placebo surgery for other misleadingly called “impingement” conditions of the shoulder (Arthroscopic subacromial decompression for subacromial shoulder pain (CSAW) + The Grumpy Shoulder). Surgery should always be surrounded by high-quality exercise encouragement, and outcomes can be predicted by the amount of hip strength you have after surgery, so there is no reason stop exercising with this type of hip pain (Postoperative Rehabilitation for Arthroscopic Management of Femoroacetabular Impingement Syndrome + A Four-Phase Physical Therapy Regimen For Returning Athletes To Sport Following Hip Arthroscopy + Hip arthroscopy versus best conservative care for the treatment of femoroacetabular impingement syndrome + Frontiers | Rehabilitation Following Hip Arthroscopy + Maximal hip muscle strength and rate of torque development 6-30 months after hip arthroscopy for femoroacetabular impingement syndrome). Any surgery for the hip should be guided by informed expectations, as it is common for those seeking and receiving surgery to have expectations of the outcomes of surgery that are not realistic (High or low return to sport rates + Mannion: Fulfilment of patient-rated expectations + Fulfilment of patient-rated expectations predicts the outcome of surgery for femoroacetabular impingement). Intolerable changes on imaging that would be the target to change with surgery include 1) flattening of the hip end of the thigh bone (called a “cam morphology”, 2) morphological change of the hip joint to increase its cover around the thigh bone (called, yes a bit threateningly, a “pincer morphology”) and/or 3) large changes to the hips labrum.
How long will it take?
The best guidelines for managing this type of hip pain recommend supervised guidance of progressive, tolerable hip exercises for at least 3 to 6 months (Physiotherapist-led treatment for young to middle-aged active adults with hip-related pain).
Busting Myths and Common Unhelpful Beliefs!
It is common to have hip changes on imaging without symptoms (How Useful Is the Alpha Angle for Discriminating between Symptomatic Patients with Cam-type Femoroacetabular Impingement and Asymptomatic Volunteers? + A Prospective Analysis of the Contralateral Hip in FAI Patients) and no symptoms in the future (Is Prophylactic Surgery for Femoroacetabular Impingement Indicated? + A Prospective Analysis of the Contralateral Hip Among Patients With Femoroacetabular Impingement). Estimates range from 70% to 100% of asymptomatic imaging findings in field-sport athletes (Mascarenhas: Imaging prevalence of FAI + What is the prevalence of extra-articular and intra-articular magnetic resonance imaging findings in football players with and without hip and/or groin pain?). You can also have similar imaging findings in the opposite, non-painful hip that remains asymptomatic in the future (A Prospective Analysis of the Contralateral Hip Among Patients With Femoroacetabular Impingement: Response - PubMed). Therefore, imaging is not helpful to make non-surgical decisions. Imaging is best used to confirm for other conditions best managed straight away with surgery (bony breaks) or aggressive rest (such as for hip stress fractures) or be used with confirmation injections (being still aware of the limitation of injections for confirming the “painful source (Utility of Intra-articular Hip Injections for Femoroacetabular Impingement) prior to planning surgery, when you have not been satisfied with high quality non-surgical management (Scan don’t cause harm, poor reasoning does + The Lisbon agreement on femoroacetabular impingement - Google Scholar + Classifying Cam Morphology by the Alpha Angle).
Surgery is not always helpful, and when encouraged with other unhelpful advice, it can have serious negative effects (Resurfacing or still drowning in despair? – Poulter’s Ponderings). A high-quality exercise program can reduce the need for the majority of people with hip pain to feel the need for surgery (Hip arthroscopy versus best conservative care for the treatment of femoroacetabular impingement syndrome).
Not all morphological changes contribute to the future risk of hip osteoarthritis (Radiographic Abnormalities Common in Senior Athletes With Well-functioning Hips but Not Associated With Osteoarthritis), and surgery is not protective of preventing future OA (Hip arthroscopy versus best conservative care for the treatment of femoroacetabular impingement syndrome (UK FASHIoN): a multicentre randomised controlled trial - PMC), so just as with what we already know about osteoarthritis risk factors, “anatomy is not a life sentence.”
Injections are often not helpful for determining the source of hip pain, contrary to what is promised (Response to diagnostic injection in patients with femoroacetabular impingement, labral tears, chondral lesions, and extra-articular pathology - PubMed).
Those who rely on manual therapy, such as massage or dry needling, without a gradual, progressive hip-loading program are often left dissatisfied in the long term despite short-term relief from many modalities (Physiotherapist-led treatment for young to middle-aged active adults with hip-related pain + Hands-On Versus Hands-Off Treatment of Hip).
What can our Physiotherapists at Method Health offer you?
We can offer individualized advice on lifestyle medicine to help you modify physical activities so you can keep up with life while managing hip pain. Hip and groin pain should not stop you from doing the things you love, and these concerns might worsen joint health anyway.
We can be your support crew, encouraging lifestyle changes that can improve your overall health, like coaching on sleep and guiding you through ways to reduce stress, or adding things to your life to better cope with the stress of a hip pain flare-up.
If you have had persistent pain and are very confused about why you still have it, we can help you make sense of the pain, highlight areas of management to prioritise or be more optimistic about, and give you individual guidance to help you manage and resolve it.
We can help you reduce your perceived need for injections or joint surgery if you do not wish to pursue these management options, or increase your realistic, evidence-informed expectations of how injections or surgery might help you. We can also help support your physical and mental preparation and return to your valued activities with less pain and discomfort if you elect for hip surgery.
More hip pain resources:
Femoroacetabular Impingement (FAI) | Mike Reiman | Ep. 049 - YouTube + Femoroacetabular Impingement with Mike Reiman - Mike Reinold
Training With Hip Pain Part IV: Femoroacetabular Impingement Syndrome | Barbell Medicine
Clinical Edge - Physio Edge -Hip pain and Femoroacetabular Impingement (FAI) with Dr Joanne Kemp + Clinical Edge - Infographic - Assessment and treatment of Femoroacetabular impingement syndrome (FAIS) - part 2 + Update Your Management Of Femoroacetabular Impingement With Dr. Jo Kemp — Physio Network
Diagnosis and Non-Operative Treatment of FAI Syndrome | SYNOPSIS + Femoroacetabular Impingement (FAI) | Diagnosis & Treatment
Advice for parents/active young adults with hip pain affecting sport:
More about "hip flexor" pain. Again, often overdiagnosed and often just a consequence of a sore hip joint.
“Strains” are unlikely in a non-sprinting mechanism. i.e., strains not common in long-distance runners, but rather referred symptoms of hip joint pain (Hip Flexor Pain | Strain | Tendinitis | Tendinopathy Rehab (Iliopsoas Strength & Mobility Exercises) + Hip flexor pain in runners: Diagnosis, myths, and rehab with Tom Goom).
Imaging is not reliable to determine if the hip flexor is the cause of pain (Can a Clinician Accurately Diagnose Iliopsoas Tendinitis on a Physical Examination? - PubMed).
Sprinting is the best exercise or vaccine for hip flexor health and for reducing injury risk (Hip Flexor Muscle Activation During Common Rehabilitation and Strength Exercises).
Be aware of non-extinct but well-intended dinosaur health care providers spreading messages that “tight” hip flexors (or “tightness” of any muscle) cause back pain, an outdated belief causing many to waste time on stretching for back pain or fear sitting for too long (Relationship between mechanical factors and incidence of low back pain + Tightness of hamstring- and psoas major muscles. A prospective study of back pain + Are you sure your hip flexors are tight? If so, why and who cares? — Greg Lehman + Do You NEED To Fix Your Posture? (Probably Not)). It's common to have sore hip muscles and back pain without them being caused by each other. Sore muscles around the same joint is common in many areas of the body due to similar risk factors for pain persistence in any muscle (Prevalence of low back pain and related disability in patients with femoroacetabular impingement syndrome).
But why do “hip flexor exercises and stretches seem to help back pain?”
1) As one risk factor is improved for persistent pain, like improving sleep health or being more active again, both back and hip pain can resolve, which might make it seem like they directly affect each other.
2) Many hip flexor “stretches” also secretly encourage movement through the lower back, improving your tolerance to these movements.
3) Any exercise that encourages time in positions more tolerable can be helpful for those with current intolerable pain. Fancy low-load “Physio” exercises like a hip flexor stretch encourage this.
4) Doing something “specific” for a few weeks (while things calm down) is reassuring and reduces the influence “concern” has on pain persistence.
5) Stretching is socially accepted for “safe” relaxation practice that replaces "dangerous" strength training. All relaxation practices are helpful for pain management of any region (To Stretch Or To Strength Train?).
6) There is no “best” exercise for back pain and it seems all tolerable exercise can improve those with back pain.
And
Groin muscle/tendon pain
Although groin muscle pain is common in those with hip joint pain and can be managed similarly, groin muscle strains or groin tendon pain can occur on their own, independent of an irritable hip joint. See the resources below for high-quality management advice for groin strains and/or tendon pain:
For other less common grumpy hip joint conditions
Hip stress fractures (a conditions where aggressive rest is best):
Hip Osteoarthritis:
Hip Osteoarthritis - E3 Rehab + Doctor of Physical Therapy Answers Your 10 Most Common Questions About Hip Osteoarthritis + Total Hip Replacement - E3 Rehab + Best Exercises After Total Hip Replacement Surgery - E3 Rehab + 224. Hip Osteoarthritis: A Practical Guide w/ Marc Surdyka and Chris Hughen + The E3 Rehab Podcast: 44. Hip Osteoarthritis & Total Hip Replacements (Top 5 Tips) w/ Mehmet Gem
NHS England » Decision support tool: making a decision about hip osteoarthritis
Hip Osteoarthritis with Dr. Joanne Kemp - Forward Physio (podcast) | Listen Notes
Hip Dysplasia:
JOSPT Insights: Ep 129: Hip dysplasia explainer (part 1), with Drs Inger Mechlenburg and Julie Jacobsen on Apple Podcasts + JOSPT Insights: Ep 130: Treating hip dysplasia (explainer part 2), with Drs Inger Mechlenburg and Julie Jacobsen on Apple Podcasts
Top tips to not miss shallow hips (HIP DYSPLASIA) Part 1 (betterclinicianproject.com) + Top tips for shallow hips (Part 2 - Dysplasia) - The clinical assessment! (betterclinicianproject.com) + Top tips for shallow hips (Part 3 - Dysplasia) - Management! (betterclinicianproject.com)
A Contemporary Definition of Hip Dysplasia and Structural Instability: Toward a Comprehensive Classification for Acetabular Dysplasia - PubMed (nih.gov)



Comments