Cortisol Catastrophising
Updated: Nov 11
The hormone cortisol historically gets a lot of hate - due to its association with blood pressure and mental stress. Yes, when persistently elevated, cortisol, and/or the context in which cortisol, blood pressure, and mental stress remain high non-volitionally, are associated with generally poor health. However, we know when cortisol is too low, we also run into health problems (Busting Myths about Cortisol with Beth Skwarecki | The Stronger By Science Podcast). So we know there is a balance, and cortisol has some essential benefits that are often not discussed. When you hear thoughts aligned with “cortisol is bad,” there is some nuance to be aware of before completely catastrophising about a “spike in cortisol”.
Cortisol increases during exercise. Is exercise bad for you?
Lots of things increase to what could appear “pathological” levels during exercise, but are normal responses to exercise, contribute to positive adaptation after exercise, and improve your tolerance to future events. Increased cortisol response to exercise was the only hormone predictive of long-term muscle gains in this study (Muscle Androgen Receptor Content but Not Systemic Hormones Is Associated With Resistance Training-Induced Skeletal Muscle Hypertrophy). Increased cortisol with exercise has shown to be protective of future cortisol increases during mental stressors (The effects of exercise intensity on the cortisol response to a subsequent acute psychosocial stressor - ScienceDirect + The anti-inflammatory effects of exercise: mechanisms and implications for the prevention and treatment of disease | Nature Reviews Immunology + Exercise and circulating cortisol levels: the intensity threshold effect - PubMed + Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Adrenal Axis Response and Recovery from High-Intensity Exercise in Women: Effects of Aging and Fitness).
Similar to how “spike in blood sugar” can be misinterpreted (Are Glucose Spikes Actually Unhealthy? | BLA 151 + Blood Glucose Spikes: How High is Too High? – Mario Kratz, PhD & Nicola Guess, PhD | Sigma Nutrition + Do Insulin Spikes cause weight gain and diabetes?), be mindful of the concern that short-term changes do not often reflect negative long-term changes.
Exercise increases blood pressure in the short term but lowers it in the long-term (Exercise and Blood Pressure).
Bone markers decrease after exercise but increase with long-term exercise exposure (Bone Health & Fall Prevention).
Elevated immune marker during exercise, but improves immune strength long-term (Debunking the Myth of Exercise-Induced Immune Suppression: Redefining the Impact of Exercise on Immunological Health Across the Lifespan - PMC + Upper respiratory tract infection is reduced in physically fit and active adults).
Exercise increase blood sugar levels, but improves sugar metabolism in the long-term (Intense Exercise Has Unique Effects on Both Insulin Release and Its Roles in Glucoregulation | Diabetes).
Increase breathing rate during exercise but reduce long-term breathing problems (Pulmonary Rehabilitation Toolkit | Lung Foundation Australia).
Cortisol levels are normally high in the morning, partially because of fasting for multiple hours, so high cortisol in the morning is normal and should not be demonised.
It is often believed that reducing cortisol as soon as possible in the morning by eating will also improve your response to exercise, or increase fat burning during exercise, but this is an unnecessary concern (Morning Routines; Female Fitness Myths).
Despite the normal rise in cortisol and changes in fat metabolism during fasted exercise (Adaptations to skeletal muscle with endurance exercise training in the acutely fed versus overnight-fasted state), these effects are not significant in the long term when energy intake is equal, whether eating or not eating in the morning during exercise. Fasted or fed exercise result in the same adaptations when actually studied long term in humans (Impact of Overnight Fasted State Versus Fed State on Adaptations to Resistance Training + Interval training in the fed or fasted state improves body composition and muscle oxidative capacity in overweight women - PubMed + Sex-based comparisons of myofibrillar protein synthesis after resistance exercise in the fed state - PubMed + The effects of nutrient timing on training adaptations in resistance-trained females - PubMed + Body composition changes associated with fasted versus non-fasted aerobic exercise). Eating or not eating before exercise should be based on personal preference and food availability, rather than on short-term changes in cortisol during exercise.
Cortisol is often criticised as “stopping fat burning.” However, fat burning does not equal fat loss. Just because you use more fat during exercise does not mean that you will lose fat that day. Fat burning during exercise does not correlate to body fat loss - because fat is constantly being simultaneously burned and stored. The balance between the two (referred to as fat balance) will determine whether or not body fat is lost (Fat burning is NOT the same thing as fat loss explanation). Also, there is evidence that a higher than normal cortisol level might be a consequence of weight gain (Cross‐sectional relation of long‐term glucocorticoids in hair with anthropometric measurements and their possible determinants), rather than a cause but still does not need to be the focus when practising sustainable strategies for weight loss (Fat Loss Myths).
Coffee consumption increases cortisol. Is coffee bad for you?
Despite cortisol increasing after caffeinated coffee consumption, benefits vastly outweigh harms with recommended amounts (Exercise and Coffee).
Also, there is no substantial evidence to suggest that coffee or caffeine contributes to an “afternoon crash” that many feel post lunch (Common questions and misconceptions about caffeine supplementation: what does the scientific evidence really show? - PMC).
Also know that with consistent daily use, the cortisol response to coffee lessens significantly (Caffeine Stimulation of Cortisol Secretion Across the Waking Hours in Relation to Caffeine Intake Levels - PMC).
Yes, persistent cortisol and general stress all day is not suitable for long-term health, and lowering it outside of the context around exercise, coffee consumption, pre-exercise nutrition, and normal, elevated morning levels should not cause concern. Ironically, although often well-intended, fearmongering about cortisol may be contributing to worse, not better, health outcomes (Cortisol 101 – DocsWhoLift + The Top Cortisol Myths in Fitness | Educational Video | Biolayne + Busting Myths about Cortisol + Excess Cortisol or Cortisol Overview and Dieting's Effects + TikTok Myth of the Week: All Your Problems Are Due to High Cortisol). Be careful of the potentially nocebic effect of well-intentioned “science-sounding” advice surrounding cortisol and other hormones blamed on reducing weight loss and increased fatigue, like the invention of “adrenal fatigue” (Adrenal Fatigue | Endocrine Society + Adrenal fatigue does not exist: a systematic review - PMC + Adrenal Fatigue: A Tired Medic… - Unbiased Science - Apple Podcasts + You don’t have adrenal fatigue – DocsWhoLift + Metabolic Damage, Adrenal Fatigue, and More. Hormones Out of Whack? Dr. Karl Nadolsky Interview - YouTube), which is unfortunately very common in healthcare. “Fear sells” (The Nocebo Effect | Annual Reviews + Placebo and Nocebo Effects on Sports and Exercise Performance + Avoiding nocebo and other undesirable effects in chiropractic, osteopathy and physiotherapy). Tell them to go sell somewhere else.



Comments