The Grumpy Knee Cap
Updated: Oct 30

Knee cap pain is medically called "patellofemoral joint pain" (PFJP) where “patello” relates to the knee cap and “femoral” relates to the front of the bottom of the thigh bone that the knee cap slides up and down during knee bending and straightening. Also referenced in research as “Anterior” knee pain and has also been harmfully called "Runners Knee."
How common is it?
Knee cap pain is the most common diagnosis for individuals under 45 years old with knee pain. It likely affects about 20% of the global population at some point in their lives (Incidence and prevalence of patellofemoral pain).
Clues or common symptoms?
Often, the description of your symptoms is enough to be confident in a management plan. Knee cap awareness usually starts without trauma, often causing people to become gradually concerned over time if it does not resolve on its own. Symptoms can start somewhat randomly over time, are often described as broad around the knee especially the lower areas around the knee cap without large amounts of swelling, bruising or knee bending apprehension (Best practice guide for patellofemoral pain based on synthesis of a systematic review, the patient voice and expert clinical reasoning). Similarly presenting non-traumatic knee pain diagnosis that might change management advice slightly include a sore “fat pad,” pain on the outside edge of the knee around the "iliotibial band" around the knee, symptoms felt directly on the lower knee cap tendon (called patellar tendon pain) or felt lower on this tendons attachment site to the shin bone (Osgood Schaltters or Sinding Larsen Johansson) (Why Your Knee Hurts - E3 Rehab). Joint music or clicking is standard for everyone with or without knee pain but is often a concern to be reassured about for those with knee cap pain, as any bodily belief reducing your confidence in your knee isn’t helpful for recovery in the long term (People's beliefs about the meaning of crepitus in patellofemoral pain and the impact of these beliefs on their behaviour + Knee crepitus is prevalent in women with patellofemoral pain, but is not related with function, physical activity and pain).

Grey shaded areas around the knee indicate where most will describe their symptoms during their sensitive movements. As you can see, it is pretty varied, which is normal and makes the diagnosis more obvious (Distinct patterns of variation in the distribution of knee pain).

What is wrong?
Knee cap pain is not associated with measurable tissue change. We do not have strongly supported theories for what specific structures around the knee cap we should target to help you reduce your symptoms over time (Comparison of symptoms and clinical findings in subgroups of individuals with patellofemoral pain - PubMed+ Patients and clinicians managing patellofemoral pain should not rely on general web-based information). The best current honest explanation should be broad and can be explained as persistent activity of complex neuro-immune systems around the knee, like a persistent headache for the knee (Patellofemoral Pain: An Enigma Explained by Homeostasis and Common Sense - PubMed). Waiting or searching for something to “heal” does not explain why people improve over time and is an approach or belief that leaves many frustrated with persistent pain. Conflicted thoughts and responses, such as “why haven't I healed yet,” lead to persistent reduced knee loading activity and are more likely to result in worse long-term outcomes (The experience of living with patellofemoral pain—loss, confusion, and fear-avoidance: a UK qualitative study). Another consequence of persistent knee pain can be weakness in the thigh and hip. Some suggest that thigh weakness contributes to causing knee cap pain, but weakness might also be a surrogate for someone who will not tolerate knee-loading tasks in the future (Talking About Knee Biomechanics | The NAF Physio).
Why me/what are my risk factors?
523 variables have been measured to determine the risk of future knee cap pain. Still, none have been strongly linked to knee cap pain yet (Factors associated with patellofemoral pain syndrome: a systematic review - PubMed). Knee cap pain is common after unrelated knee surgery, likely due to returning too quickly to any knee loading tasks after the planned reduction in movement tolerance post surgery. Females have more reported of knee cap pain but biomechanical and hormone theories have not been supported by substantial research (Patellar Maltracking Persists in Adolescent Females With Patellofemoral Pain: A Longitudinal Study - PMC + Cycles and Strains: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of the Influence of the Menstrual Cycle on Muscle Injuries + Prevalence of anterior knee pain in 18-35 year-old females - PubMed + (PDF) Considerations for coaches training female athletes). So overall, the most identifiable factor initiating knee pain is either a rapid increase in any type of knee loading maybe also with a background of lifestyle factors that reduce recovery and tissue capacity such as increased negative mental stress, weeks to months of low level of physical activity before beginning a leg loading exercise habit, reduced sleep or illness (2016 Patellofemoral pain consensus statement from the 4th International Patellofemoral Pain Research Retreat, Manchester. Part 1: Terminology, definitions, clinical examination, natural history, patellofemoral osteoarthritis, and patient-reported outcome measures + Chronic lack of sleep is associated with increased sports injuries in adolescent athletes - PubMed).
What can I do about it?
The four most supported strategies for managing knee cap pain from most important to least important include:
Find a tolerable starting dosage for your sensitive knee loading task and then gradually build up tolerance to this activity (Patellofemoral Pain in Adolescents | Activity Modification and Load Management). Running, gym exercises, and sports movements. Find a tolerable dose and make measurable, gradual progress over several months. Many try to progress within days or weeks and run into difficulty tolerating these rapid progressions.
For runners: Try increasing step rate/cadence by 5-10 steps per minute (this phone App can be helpful) or switching to a forefoot or front of foot running patterns (be aware the trade-off of these gait patters is that running load is shifted away from the knee to the more calf/achilles so be stil be careful with“too much too soon”) or trialling different terrains types (sand/grass/rubber or cement) (Effects of rehabilitation approaches for runners with patellofemoral pain: protocol of a randomised clinical trial addressing specific underlying mechanismst + Effects of Step Rate Manipulation on Joint Mechanics during Running - PMC).
Feel free to cross-train or engage in different, more tolerable types of exercise to continue meeting the Australian physical activity guidelines while gradually increasing your tolerance to your preferred but sensitive exercise modes.

Increase the strength of muscles around the knee, hip, and ankle through regular weekly strength training. Squatting, leg press, lunges, step-ups, single-leg deadlifts, hip thrusts, calf raises are all good choices to do with increasingly heavy weights 2-3x week (Trunk, Hip and Knee Exercise Programs for Pain Relief, Functional Performance and Muscle Strength in Patellofemoral Pain).

Improving lifestyle stress while reducing unhelpful negative pain beliefs can improve the ability to recover from strategy number 1 of progressive knee loading. Improving sleep and either reducing mental stress or planning stress-coping strategies, such as exercise, good nutrition, or engaging in other enjoyable hobbies, can help manage knee cap pain. Reframe harmful beliefs such as “pain means knee damage” or “this is never going to get better” to “movement can be safe, strong, and sore” and “I trust my healthy habits will help me reduce my knee aches and pains over time” (Modern Pain Care For Patellofemoral Pain Syndrome).
Temporarily trial orthotics/footwear change and/or foot or knee bracing. No footwear, taping, or orthotic type is the “best.” (Do biomechanical foot-based interventions reduce patellofemoral joint loads in adults with and without patellofemoral pain or osteoarthritis?+ Knee orthoses for treating patellofemoral pain syndrome - PubMed + How To Choose The Best Running Shoes - E3 Rehab). Finding something that works is usually a game of trial and error. Again, this does not need to be a long-term change.
Long-term knee cap pain has been shown in some studies to increase the risk of future knee cap osteoarthritis (Patellofemoral pain consensus- Terminology, definitions, clinical examination, natural history, patellofemoral osteoarthritis and patient-reported outcome measures - PMC). It is not clear if they are directly related, or if those with knee cap pain have behaviours such as reduced physical activity, weight gain and reduced mental health that also increase the risk of future joint symptoms (Knee Osteoarthritis (OA). Either way, improving your joint health when you have knee cap pain will reduce your risk of future knee OA.
How long will it take to recover?
Often, weekly patient treatment of the above four supported knee cap pain management strategies will help most patients feel significantly better within 3 to 6 months or sooner (PFPS Consensus Statement). More time might be needed by those who have difficulty completing the top 3 strategies. Some individuals can experience a sore unsatisfactory kneecap pain for multiple years if not managed with up-to-date management strategies (The experience of living with patellofemoral pain—loss, confusion, and fear-avoidance: a UK qualitative study).
Busting Myths and Common Beliefs about Knee Cap Pain
Knee cap pressure or pain does not consistently increase at the same amount as the knee bends more (Contact stresses in the knee joint in deep flexion - ScienceDirect). More bending does not equal more pressure.
Knee cap pain is not caused by “soft” bones or joint surface (No Difference on Quantitative Magnetic Resonance Imaging in Patellofemoral Cartilage Composition Between Patients With Patellofemoral Pain and Healthy Controls). If you hear that description or are given the diagnosis of ““Chondromalacia Patella” from a likely well-intentioned clinician, it is outdated, and so might be their advice. Or you may actually have knee cap osteoarthritis, which can show joint changes on imaging. See this article for more information about the management of knee osteoarthritis (OA), which is similar to the management of knee cap pain.
If you are temporarily trying to relieve “stress” on your knee cap, you don’t need to avoid the Knee/leg extension exercise. Knee extensions are not more stressful on the knee joint than squats or leg press, despite opinions still popular across the internet (Patellofemoral joint stress during weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing quadriceps exercises - PubMed).
Anatomical and "alignment" measures have not been found as strongly predictive of future knee cap pain and aren’t non-invasively modifiable anyway (Risk factors for patellofemoral pain+ Healthy knees have a highly variable patellofemoral alignment). These factors also don’t need to change for your symptoms to improve (Patellar Maltracking Persists in Adolescent Females With Patellofemoral Pain + How to help knee pain without ever changing knee valgus + The effect of a hip-strengthening program on mechanics during running and during a single-leg squat + Changes in knee biomechanics after a hip-abductor strengthening protocol for runners with patellofemoral pain syndrome).
Knee or hip joint flexibility does not predict future knee cap pain (Factors associated with patellofemoral pain syndrome: a systematic review | British Journal of Sports Medicine).
Paradoxically, foot posture does not strongly predict future knee pain (Foot posture as a risk factor for lower limb overuse injury: a systematic review and meta‐analysis - Neal - 2014 - Journal of Foot and Ankle Research - Wiley Online Library), but foot orthotic and/or footwear change can be helpful for some people (How To Choose The Best Running Shoes - E3 Rehab).
Targeting the inner quadriceps muscle group, medically known as the vastus medialis obliques (VMO), is not necessary to reduce knee pain for multiple reasons:
It is not very distinct from the actions and functions of the other thigh muscles.
You can’t isolate the VMO with exercise anyway.
The tightness of any of the thigh muscles does not predict future knee cap pain or “strain the knee cap outwards” as some mistakenly thought.
Just getting all thigh muscles stronger works just as well as trying to target the VMO (Vastus medialis obliquus (VMO) retraining or graduated loading programme for patellofemoral pain: different paradigm with similar results? | British Journal of Sports Medicine).
Exercise and good education are better than doing nothing and “waiting to recover” (Comparative effectiveness of treatments for patellofemoral pain: a living systematic review with network meta-analysis - PMC).
Surgery is not helpful for persistent knee cap pain (Knee arthroscopy and exercise versus exercise only for chronic patellofemoral pain syndrome: 5-year follow-up | British Journal of Sports Medicine).
Manual therapy options such as massage or mobilisation, needling, and all electrophysical modalities lack strong research to support encouraging their use (Patellofemoral Pain: Clinical Practice Guidelines Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy).
What can our Physiotherapists at Method Health offer you?
We can offer individualized advice to help you modify your activities and manage knee cap pain, allowing you to continue with your daily life. Knee cap pain should not stop you from doing the things you love. This might involve discussing a strength training and knee cap loading routine to support you in getting back to the activities you enjoy, which you may have reduced or avoided.
We can help with taping and orthotic choice if you decide these will be helpful.
We can be your support team to encourage lifestyle changes that can improve your overall health, such as coaching on sleep, guiding you through ways to reduce stress, or introducing activities to help you better cope with stress.
Do you have persistent knee cap pain and are unsure why you still experience it? In that case, we can help you make sense of the pain, highlight areas for management prioritization, offer more optimistic perspectives, and provide individual guidance to assist in managing and resolving it.




Comments