Managing Menopause
Updated: 7 days ago
“Does menopause affect my body fat, muscle mass, and ability to progress with exercise?”
Menopause is defined as a 12 month period of an absence of ovulation. The menstrual cycle training section our Women's Health article, should help explain why a 12-month absence of a period does not define menopause, as it historically did, and why defining the true start of menopause is more difficult than promised. Menopause is often experienced as a confusing and life-changing 5-15 year period with a spectrum of physical and mental symptoms. On average, menopause is recognised by the age of 51 in women, but symptoms of peri-menopause, when your ovaries are still producing normal amounts of oestrogen, can occur years earlier (Menopause | Nature Reviews Disease Primers + Moderate to severe vasomotor and sexual symptoms remain problematic for women aged 60 to 65 years - PubMed + Navigating Menopause: Expert Insights and Solutions (Part 1) | Dr S.Davis + Part 2 + Information About Menopause - YouTube + Position Papers and Consensus Statements - International Menopause Society + Bothersome vasomotor symptoms: a potential early clinical marker of perimenopause?). To emphasise, the confusing life changing symptoms of menopause are still occurring when oestrogen levels are normal and many complex changes not validated well by blood hormone levels explain these symptoms better (Lecture | Cardiometabolic Health: Do Sex Steroids Matter?- YouTube). Like anything complex, misinformation is common, even when well-intentioned. Unfortunately, the marketing of hormone-based medication, supplementation, and health advice targets all women at this vulnerable stage, who often have a strong, very reasonable desire to solve the confusing symptoms of menopause with any promised "quick hormone fix." Many experience these unproven medical promises through social media. These women's health marketing companies, with a very confident individual as their spokesperson, use a simple, "common sense" message that the exact amount of estrogen reduction causes all these confusing symptoms, and that only what they are selling can resolve what you want to change. What is sold is often not effective and is credited with improvements in symptoms that are actually helped by the other lifestyle changes encouraged as part of the supplement sale (Marketing empowerment: how corporations co-opt feminist narratives to promote non-evidence based health interventions | The BMJ + “Menopause is not a dirty word.” Australian women's opinions about increased public attention to menopause + Wild West or Gold Rush: How Long-Neglected Menopause Care Has Spawned a Booming Marketplace).
Is muscle loss and fat gain inevitable in menopause?
Common menopause misinformation that is harmful and uses fear to sell unproven supplements or health books includes the myth around the “inevitability” of fat gain and muscle loss during menopause, independent of the effects of healthy aging. Like other common examples for women during their lifetime, such as during pregnancy or after reading about the side effects of some medication, a woman who believes weight gain and muscle loss are inevitable will not take daily actions to prevent weight gain and muscle loss. These misbeliefs, and how they contribute to unnecessary fat gain and muscle loss they have a daily impact on women and make peri- and post-menopause unnecessarily difficult (Gains in Body Fat and Vasomotor Symptom Reporting Over the Menopausal Transition). Despite common cultural beliefs, muscle loss and weight/fat gain during menopause are more related to lifestyle changes in response to "inevitable worsening health beliefs" and intolerable menopause symptoms, all contributing to less physical activity, worse daily nutrition habits, and unhealthy aging. We know these harmful beliefs and lifestyle changes, made to desperately cope with the symptoms you experience during menopause, are more important to focus on the "inevitable negative" sounding effect of oestrogen changes that are occurring during midlife (Changes in body composition and weight during the menopause transition + Changes in physical activity and body composition in postmenopausal women over time - PubMed + Metabolic health, menopause, and physical activity-a 4-year follow-up study + Menopause 101 | Docs Who Lift Podcast + Changes in Regional Fat Distribution and Anthropometric Measures Across the Menopause Transition + Is Weight Loss Resistance Real? - Dr Bill Campbell + Body composition and cardiometabolic health across the menopause transition + Weight Regulation in Menopause). Also be reassured that:
Muscle and fat changes occur at the same rate for males and females who are the same ages, disputing any unique influence of menopause on body composition (Influence of age and gender on fat mass, fat-free mass and skeletal muscle mass among Australian adults + Assessment of Age-Induced Changes in Body Fat Percentage + Changes in body composition and weight during the menopause transition).
Changes in metabolism with healthy aging are so small as they are likely unnoticeable compared to lifestyle changes that interrupt your ability to maintain healthy aging habits. Studies with thousands of participants have undramatically shown that metabolism is stable on average until 60 years old on average in either sex. This is 10 years after average menopause changes begin for females, and again is so small it takes laboratory based measurement to detect this small change. Also, some of these small changes we think can be attributed to changes in oestrogen, only occur during the first years of peri-menopause and do not progress or worsen with time as many still fear-monger (Daily energy expenditure through the human life course + Age But Not Menopausal Status Is Linked to Lower Resting Energy Expenditure). Any other change in fat, muscle mass, or metabolism unaccounted for by lifestyle changes coincidentally common during menopause, such as increased attention on child-raising, increased work commitments/responsibilities, caring for less independent parents (all resulting in changes to nutrition, sleep and exercise habits) can be explained by the effects of healthy aging.
Women mistakenly perceive fat redistribution towards the belly away from other body areas due to menopausal changes as fat gain, even though no fat gain has occurred (Are hormones the key to weight loss?). Just like how fluid can shift around your body, so can where your current fat is stored. So don't mistake this for fat gain, just like youwouldn'tt for fluid retention after a high-salt meal. This makes heaps of sense as another reason why "belly fat gain" after doing "nothing different for months" strengthens the thoughts and habits that actually contribute to fat gain, like moving less and eating more, keeping women in an unnecessary cycle of fat gain.
Symptoms of menopause and associated life stress common at this time of life for most families greatly contribute to behaviours that contribute to weight gain (Menopausal symptoms: do life events predict severity of symptoms in peri- and post-menopause? + Sleep and sleep disorders in the menopausal transition), and can make weight loss or maintaining your body weight difficult for some women. Still, many women going through menopause do not experience weight gain (Effects of the menopausal transition on dietary intake and appetite) again pointing to the fact that while menopausal changes might make weight loss or weight maintenance more difficult, fat gain is not inevitable.
Again, as addressed in the “Is it harder for women to lose weight than men?” section in our Method Health Women's Health, be careful of beliefs that “losing weight will be harder for me than others” as we know this makes general weight loss more difficult than it needs to be (Mind over milkshakes: mindsets, not just nutrients, determine ghrelin response). Do the social messages of “inevitable weight gain” during and after menopause reduce your belief that fat loss habits will be helpful. The belief of “inevitable” changes can be a strong barrier to weight loss attempts and maintenance due to how it reduces your confidence in healthy daily behaviour. Again, mindset matters much more than the direct effects of oestrogen changes during menopause, and thankfully is more modifiable.
Some might be thinking about the effects of menopause hormone therapy (MHT) and how this influences body composition, including fat mass, bone and muscle. While being very helpful for many women (when accessible and not always in a “more is better” way) to reduce some symptoms of menopause when negatively affecting quality of life (Treatment of Symptoms of the Menopause: An Endocrine Society Clinical Practice Guideline + What We Should Know About Perimenopause + Low use of effective and safe therapies for moderate to severe menopausal symptoms: a cross-sectional community study of Australian women + Your Brain On... Menopause Hormones - Apple Podcasts + Your Brain On...Testosterone Apple Podcasts + NAMS 2022 Hormone Therapy Position Statement + Addressing the “Women Have More Testosterone Than Estrogen” Claim), MHT aims to increase oestrogen and/or testosterone does not prevent the small amounts of muscle loss associated with the normal healthy aging during this time. Again, strength training is your best option here for improving your body composition during this time (Association Between Hormone Therapy and Muscle Mass in Postmenopausal Women + Is Testosterone Just for Men? The Science of Women’s Hormones & Health | Susan Davis + Women’s sexual health, menopause, and hormone replacement therapy (HRT) + The Truth About Hormone Replacement Therapy). We wish it would be as simple as just raising hormones with medication to have the body composition goals you are aspiring to, but multiple lines of evidence suggest this is not helpful to depend on. Focus on lifestyle factors, exercise and for some the assistance of hormone therapy, to help manage the symptoms of menopause to positively influence your body composition during this time, rather than being concerned about “inevitable hormone effects.”
Finally, the research from which this menopause belief that a reduction in metabolism occurs dramatically due to changes in oestrogen, occurred from studying laboratory female rats after their ovaries were surgically removed. This is not comparable to the changes occurring in a woman throughout menopause. We have other glands in our body that still produce oestrogen after menopause, whereas rats do not. This also points to another misconception that oestrogen production completely stops in women post-menopause. If this were true, women would have little risk of developing breast and uterine cancer.
So to summarise, negative muscle, fat and metabolic changes during menopause match what we would expect in males of the same age and are so small, you won’t notice them compared to the effects of lifestyle changes at this time. However, it is much easier to blame menopause, than change difficult lifestyle situations, so this common misconception remains “common knowledge.” As we have said, maintaining healthy lifestyle habits is very important during this time. Those who maintain consistent strength exercise during peri-menopause and post-menopause years do not see small amounts of weight gain, bone density reduction or muscle loss many still unfortunately believe as “inevitable.” These measures only improve with progressive strength training (Preventing muscle and bone loss in peri-menopausal and early post-menopausal females with heavy strength and impact training + Resistance training predicts 6-yr body composition change in postmenopausal women). Your metabolism hasn’t slowed down. You have. So spread the word that menopause does not affect your potential to gain strength, muscle or reduce body fat from a strength training program. However, an unhealthy lifestyle at any stage of life, sometimes due to unpredictable life events with a lack of time management skills and/or social support around you to maintain healthy lifestyle habits to cope with, definitely can (Evaluation of sex-based differences in resistance exercise training-induced changes in muscle mass, strength, and physical performance in healthy older (≥60 y) adults + Sex Differences in Adaptations in Muscle Strength and Size Following Resistance Training in Older Adults + It's never too late: The impact of resistance training on strength and body composition in females across the lifespan + Resistance training alters body composition in middle-aged women depending on menopause).
How can hard exercise help you manage this phase of you life as part of your healthy aging wishes?
While just as beneficial for any age group, exercise is particularly beneficial during and after this time period for women, especially if you are concerned about changes in bone health, body fat, muscle mass, strength, aerobic fitness and menopausal symptoms like hot flashes, sleep difficulty, changed mood and fatigue (Optimizing Female Health: The Crucial Role of Exercise Initiation before and during the Menopausal Transition). Low-intensity aerobic activity like walking, house work, movement as part of your occupation and what are often sold as the safest and most tolerable "strength" exercise options including yoga, stretching, and pilates are all 1) fine to start with and 2) good for recovery from stressful days. However, as low-intensity forms of activity they are 1) not as time-efficient for achieving and maintaining high quality of life levels of aerobic fitness like running and sport (50 Benefits of Aerobic Training or Planned Progressive Physical Activity), 2) not as time-efficient for improving muscle and bone health as strengthening exercise using progressive weights over time rather then just your bodyweight (50 Benefits of Strength Training) and 3) if chosen over tolerable higher intensity dosages of exercise, promise fewer benefits for menopausal symptoms and health post-menopause than these, yes, more difficult options that when not supported well can feel "not worth the risk" (The effects of aerobic exercise on cardiometabolic health in postmenopausal females + Strength training during peri-menopause and menopause + Resistance training predicts 6-yr body composition change in postmenopausal women - PubMed + The effect of resistance training programs on lean body mass in postmenopausal and older women: a meta-analysis of observational studies + Dose–Response Relationship of Resistance Training on Metabolic Phenotypes, Body Composition and Lipid Profile in Menopausal Women + Resistance training for postmenopausal women: systematic review and meta-analysis + The Efficacy of Strength Exercises for Reducing the Symptoms of Menopause: A Systematic Review + Effects of Physical Activity on Vasomotor Symptoms: Examination Using Objective and Subjective Measures + Effects of resistance training on quality of life in postmenopausal women with vasomotor symptoms + The effect of resistance training in reducing hot flushes in post-menopausal women: A meta-analysis + Dose–response effects of exercise training on the subjective sleep quality of postmenopausal women: exploratory analyses of a randomised controlled trial - PMC + Pelvic floor muscle training: mechanisms of action for the improvement of genitourinary syndrome of menopause + Talking About Older Females Lifting Heavy Sh*t. - Apple Podcasts + Nutrition and Exercise Interventions to Improve Body Composition for Persons with Overweight or Obesity Near Retirement Age: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials). The evidence provided in our Women's Health and Common Barriers To Exercise Method Health articles should also challenge any other barrier and unhelpful belief that you should not seek support to start, increase or continue more aerobic and strength exercise you complete each week.
More menopause support:
Menopause, Part 1: What It Actually Is and the 24-Year WHI Correction - YouTube + Menopause, Part 2: The 2,000-Year-Old Lie About Women and Exercise + Body Composition, Bone, Brain, & the Fitness Changes (Data vs the Influencers) I Menopause Part 3 + Women’s Health Consultation with Dr. Loraine Baraki | Barbell Medicine + Menopause & Strength Training: What Actually Works (The Evidence) I Part IV
Menopause Information & Support | Australasian Menopause Society
Dr. Jen Gunter
Women’s health misinformation | Dr Jen Gunter, OB, GYN - The Proof (We apologise in advance for the sponsors of this show which are unfortunately sometimes outdated. Hopefully this is not a barrier for trusting who is being interviewed). Here is more from the guest- A Five-Step Guide to Combating Misinformation on Social Media + The Truth About Women’s Hormone Therapy | Dr. Jen Gunter
Lauren Colenso-Semple
Dr. Lauren CS | Substack + Lauren Colenso-Semple, PhD (@drlaurencs1) • Instagram
Lauren Colenso-Semple, PhD (@drlaurencs1) • Instagram photos and videos + Women's Fitness Myths, Cycle Syncing, & Fasted Cardio DEBUNKED with Dr. Lauren Colenso-Semple + Episode 379: Menopause Myths, Cortisol Belly, & The Truth About IUDs + Female-Specific Training & What the Science Really Says | Dr. Lauren Colenso-Semple
Susan Davis
Susan Davis Archives - The Proof (We apologise in advance for the sponsors of this show which are unfortunately sometimes outdated. Hopefully this is not a barrier for trusting who is being interviewed)
Why didn't anyone tell me this? Prof Susan Davis: Making sense of the menopause - YouTube
Other trustworthy women’s health resources/leaders:
Women's Health Consultation with Dr. Loraine Baraki - Barbell Medicine
Dr Margie Davenport Expert of Pregnancy & Postpartum Health (@drmargiedavenport) • Instagram photos and videosDr. Christina Prevett PT, PhD (@dr.christina_prevett) • Instagram photos and videos
Nicole Surdyka DPT, CSCS, CPSS (@dr.nicolept) • Instagram photos and videos
Dr Claire Minshull - Get Back To Sport + 074 Talking About Strength and... - The NAF Physio Podcast - Apple Podcasts
Andrea C. Love, PhD (@dr.andrealove) • Instagram photos and videos
Dr. Gabrielle Fundaro, CHC (@trust_and_nourish) • Instagram photos and videos + Gabrielle Fundaro, PhD, CHC (@no_bs_guthealth) • Instagram photos and videosKelly McNulty, PhD (@periodoftheperiod) • Instagram photos and videos
Movement Logic Tutorials (@movementlogictutorials) • Instagram photos and videos




Comments